Health insurance cooperatives are member-owned organisations that pool members' health insurance premiums to provide medical coverage. Unlike commercial insurers, surpluses are returned to members rather than to outside shareholders. In the United States, the Affordable Care Act created Consumer Operated and Oriented Plans (CO-OPs) to introduce cooperative competition into the individual and small group insurance markets. Internationally, cooperative and mutual health insurers cover hundreds of millions of people.
Types of Health Insurance Cooperatives
US Consumer Operated and Oriented Plans (CO-OPs)
Nonprofit health insurers established under Section 1322 of the Affordable Care Act, governed by a board elected by enrolled members, and required to return surpluses to members as lower premiums or expanded benefits. CO-OPs received federal loans under the ACA to provide startup and solvency capital.
Of the 23 CO-OPs funded by the ACA starting in 2014, most have closed due to insufficient risk pool capitalisation, adverse selection, and the elimination of federal risk corridor payments. As of 2024, fewer than 5 ACA CO-OPs remain operational, including Maine Community Health Options.
CO-OPs must be licensed by the state insurance department in each state where they sell coverage. Federal oversight is provided by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Governance requirements include that enrolled members hold a majority of seats on the board of directors.
Group Health Cooperatives
Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound, founded in 1947 in Seattle, was one of the largest and most successful health insurance cooperatives in US history. At its peak it served 700,000+ members across Washington and Idaho. It merged with Kaiser Permanente in 2017. The Group Health model combined insurance with direct provision of medical services — members received care at Group Health clinics staffed by salaried physicians.
HealthPartners in Minnesota operates as a consumer cooperative and is one of the largest nonprofit health insurers in the Upper Midwest. It covers approximately 1.8 million members and operates its own medical clinics and Regions Hospital.
A smaller, member-governed health insurance cooperative operating in Madison, Wisconsin since 1976. Serves approximately 70,000 members. One of the few remaining independent consumer health cooperatives operating the combined insurance-and-care model.
International Health Cooperative Models
The largest medical cooperative system in the world, with over 100,000 physician-owners organised into regional cooperatives under the UNIMED brand. UNIMED covers approximately 18 million Brazilians and operates its own hospitals, diagnostic centres, and insurance products.
P&V Assurances is a Belgian mutual and cooperative insurer covering approximately 1 million members across health, auto, and life insurance. Surpluses are distributed to members through premium reductions and solidarity actions.
France's mutuelle system provides supplementary health coverage (complementaire santé) to approximately 90% of the population through approximately 450 mutual health organisations. Mutuelles are regulated by the Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution (ACPR).
How Health Insurance Cooperatives Differ from Commercial Insurers
The structural difference is ownership: commercial health insurers are owned by investors who receive dividends from underwriting profits. Health insurance cooperatives are owned by members — either policyholders (consumer cooperative model) or healthcare providers (like UNIMED's physician-member model). In the cooperative model, there is no shareholder dividend competing with member value. Surpluses can be returned as premium reductions, improved benefits, or retained as capital reserves. Cooperatives also have governance obligations to members: board elections, transparent financial reporting, and member participation in major decisions.
Challenges Facing Health Insurance Cooperatives
Health insurance cooperatives face structural challenges that make them more difficult to sustain than other cooperative types. Insurance requires large risk pools to spread actuarial risk — smaller cooperatives face adverse selection (sicker members disproportionately joining) and higher administrative cost ratios. The failure of most ACA CO-OPs demonstrated that startup cooperative health insurers are particularly vulnerable to under-capitalisation and to policy changes (the elimination of federal risk corridor payments was a significant factor in many CO-OP failures). Existing large health cooperatives like HealthPartners and Group Health of South Central Wisconsin have survived by maintaining large, stable member bases and integrating insurance with direct care provision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I join a health insurance cooperative?
In the US, the remaining health insurance cooperatives — like HealthPartners, Group Health of South Central Wisconsin, and Maine Community Health Options — offer coverage to eligible residents in their service areas through the ACA marketplace and group plans. Coverage availability depends on your location. In other countries, cooperative and mutual health insurers are often widely available — in France, virtually all employees have access to a mutuelle through their employer.
What happened to the ACA CO-OPs?
Most of the 23 CO-OPs established under the ACA closed between 2015 and 2020. Key failure factors were: insufficient startup capital relative to actuarial risk, adverse selection, the elimination of federal risk corridor payments that were designed to protect against losses in early years, and competition from established commercial insurers with larger risk pools and established provider networks.
How do cooperative health insurers handle surpluses?
Surpluses are handled as specified in the cooperative's bylaws and subject to insurance regulatory requirements. Common approaches: premium rebates or reductions for the following year, credits applied to member accounts, investments in expanded benefits or new facilities, and additions to capital reserves. US health insurers (including cooperatives) are subject to the ACA's Medical Loss Ratio rules requiring that at least 80–85% of premiums be spent on medical care.
What is the difference between a cooperative health insurer and a mutual health insurer?
In the US, the terms are often used interchangeably. Technically, a mutual insurer is owned by policyholders under a mutual insurance company legal structure. A cooperative health insurer is organised under cooperative law with explicit cooperative governance principles. Both return surpluses to members rather than external shareholders. Outside the US, mutuelles (France) and mutual societies (UK) operate under distinct legal frameworks from cooperatives, though the economic logic is similar.
Related Resources
Find Cooperatives
Browse 26,000+ cooperatives by sector, country, and size in our free directory.